Question Details

Which among the following reagent can be used to distinguish between CH₂BrCH=CH₂ from CH3CH=CHBr?

Options

A

Br₂/CCl₄

B

cold KMnO₄

C

AgNO₃/C₂H₅OH

D

Ag(NH₃)₂OH

Correct Answer :

AgNO₃/C₂H₅OH

Solution :

The correct answer is AgNO₃/C₂H₅OH.

To understand why ethanolic silver nitrate (AgNO3/C2H5OH) can be used to distinguish between allyl bromide (CH2BrCH=CH2) and 1-bromoprop-1-ene (CH3CH=CHBr), let us analyze the reactivity of the bromine atom in each compound towards nucleophilic substitution reactions.

1. Allyl bromide (CH2BrCH=CH2):
In allyl bromide, the bromine atom is attached to an sp3 hybridized carbon atom adjacent to a carbon-carbon double bond. When treated with ethanolic silver nitrate, the weak carbon-bromine bond easily cleaves to form a carbocation:
CH2Br-CH=CH2+Ag+[CH2-CH=CH2]++AgBr
The resulting allylic carbocation ([CH2-CH=CH2]+) is highly stable due to resonance. Because of this high stability, allyl bromide readily undergoes nucleophilic substitution and precipitates silver bromide (AgBr) as a light yellow precipitate rapidly at room temperature.

2. 1-Bromoprop-1-ene (CH3CH=CHBr):
In 1-bromoprop-1-ene, the bromine atom is directly attached to an sp2 hybridized carbon atom (a vinyl halide). The lone pairs of electrons on the bromine atom are in conjugation with the π-bond of the double bond, which gives the carbon-bromine bond partial double-bond character due to resonance:
CH3-CH=CH-Br¨CH3-CH--CH=Br+
This partial double-bond character makes the C-Br bond extremely strong and difficult to break. Consequently, vinylic halides do not react with ethanolic AgNO3 under ordinary conditions, and no precipitate is observed.

Why other options are incorrect:
- Br₂/CCl₄: Both compounds contain a carbon-carbon double bond, so both will decolorize the reddish-brown bromine solution.
- cold KMnO₄ (Baeyer's reagent): Both compounds are unsaturated and will decolorize cold, alkaline potassium permanganate, turning it from purple to a brown precipitate of MnO2.
- Ag(NH₃)₂OH (Tollens' reagent): This reagent is used for detecting terminal alkynes or aldehydes, and neither of these compounds reacts with it.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemistry, mathematics, physics

  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemistry, mathematics, physics