Question Details

Two concentric shells of different masses m1 and m2 are having a sliding particle of mass m. The forces on the particle at position A, B and C are

Options

A

0, Gm₁/r₂², G(m₁+m₂)m/r₁²

B

Gm₂/r₂², 0 , Gm₁/r₁²

C

G(m₁+m₂)m/r₁², Gm₂/r₂², 0

D

G(m₁+m₂)m/r₁², Gm₁/r₂², 0

Correct Answer :

G(m₁+m₂)m/r₁², Gm₁/r₂², 0

Solution :

The correct answer is: G(m₁+m₂)m/r₁², Gm₁/r₂��, 0 (noting that in the second term, the mass of the particle m is omitted in the option text).

To understand this result, we use the Shell Theorem of gravitation:
1. Outside a spherical shell: The gravitational force exerted by a uniform spherical shell on a point mass outside it is calculated by assuming the entire mass of the shell is concentrated at its center.
2. Inside a spherical shell: The gravitational force exerted by a uniform spherical shell on a point mass placed anywhere inside it is exactly zero.

Let the two concentric shells have mass m1 (inner shell) and m2 (outer shell). The particle has mass m.

Step 1: Force at Position A (outside both shells)
Let position A be at a distance r1 from the common center, where r1 is greater than the radii of both shells.
Since the particle is outside both shells, both shells attract it as if their masses were concentrated at the center. Thus, the total gravitational force is:

FA=G(m1+m2)mr12

Step 2: Force at Position B (between the two shells)
Let position B be at a distance r2 from the common center, lying between the inner and outer shells.
- Since the particle is inside the outer shell (m2), the gravitational force exerted on it by the outer shell is zero.
- Since the particle is outside the inner shell (m1), the inner shell attracts it as if its entire mass is concentrated at the center.
Therefore, the force at B is due only to the inner shell:

FB=Gm1mr22

Step 3: Force at Position C (inside both shells)
Let position C be inside both shells.
Since the particle is inside both the inner and outer shells, the gravitational force exerted on it by both shells is zero:

FC=0

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemistry, mathematics, physics

  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemical engineering, mathematics, physics