Given below are two statements and four conclusions drawn based on the statements.
Statement 1 : Some bottles are cups.
Statement 2 :All cups are knives.
Conclusion I : Some bottles are knives.
Conclusion II : Some knives are cups.
Conclusion III : All cups are bottles.
Conclusion IV : All knives are cups.
Which one of the following options can be logically inferred?
Correct Answer :
Only conclusion I and conclusion II are correct
Solution :
The correct option is: Only conclusion I and conclusion II are correct.
Let us analyze the given statements step-by-step to evaluate the validity of each conclusion:
Statement 1: "Some bottles are cups."
This statement indicates that there is an intersection between the set of bottles and the set of cups. That is, at least some items are both bottles and cups.
Statement 2: "All cups are knives."
This statement means that the set of cups is entirely contained within the set of knives. Any item that is a cup is automatically a knife.
Now, let us evaluate the conclusions based on these relations:
Conclusion I: "Some bottles are knives."
Since "Some bottles are cups" (Statement 1) and "All cups are knives" (Statement 2), the bottles that are cups must also be knives. Therefore, there must be some bottles that are knives. This conclusion is logically correct.
Conclusion II: "Some knives are cups."
From Statement 2, we know that "All cups are knives". As long as the set of cups is non-empty (which is implied by "Some bottles are cups"), any cup is also a knife. Thus, we can logically infer that at least some knives are cups. This conclusion is logically correct.
Conclusion III: "All cups are bottles."
Statement 1 only asserts that "Some bottles are cups". This does not mean that every cup is a bottle. We cannot logically conclude that all cups are bottles. Thus, this conclusion is incorrect.
Conclusion IV: "All knives are cups."
Statement 2 tells us that "All cups are knives". This means the set of cups is a subset of the set of knives, but the set of knives can be larger than the set of cups. We cannot logically infer that every knife is a cup. Thus, this conclusion is incorrect.
Based on the analysis, only Conclusion I and Conclusion II are logically valid.
Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.
Create, conduct, and manage professional online assessments with Crey. Perfect for teachers and institutes.
Copyright © 2026 Crey. All Rights Reserved.