Question Details

Mark the wrong statement

Options

A

Sliding of molecular layer is much easier than compression or expansion

B

Reciprocal of bulk modulus of elasticity is called compressibility

C

It is difficult to twist a long rod as compared to small rod

D

Hollow shaft is much stronger than a solid rod of same length and same mass

Correct Answer :

It is difficult to twist a long rod as compared to small rod

Solution :

The correct answer is: "It is difficult to twist a long rod as compared to small rod".

Let us analyze each statement to understand why this is the incorrect (wrong) statement among the choices:

1. Sliding of molecular layer is much easier than compression or expansion:
When a material undergoes shearing stress, the molecular layers slide over one another. This shape deformation does not change the volume, which requires overcoming intermolecular repulsive or attractive forces to a much smaller degree than changing the volume (compression or expansion). Therefore, the shear modulus (associated with sliding/shearing) is generally much smaller than the bulk modulus (associated with compression/expansion), making sliding much easier. This statement is correct.

2. Reciprocal of bulk modulus of elasticity is called compressibility:
By definition, compressibility is the measure of the relative volume change of a fluid or solid as a response to a pressure change. Mathematically, compressibility (C) is the reciprocal of the bulk modulus (B):
C=1B
This statement is correct.

3. It is difficult to twist a long rod as compared to small rod:
The restoring torque (τ) required to produce an angle of twist θ in a cylinder/rod of length l, radius r, and shear modulus η is given by the relation:
τ=πηr4θ2l
From this formula, we can see that the torque required to twist a rod by a certain angle θ is inversely proportional to its length (l):
τ1l
This means that for a longer rod (larger l), the torque required to produce the same angle of twist is smaller. In other words, it is actually easier to twist a long rod than a short (small) rod of the same material and radius. Thus, the statement "It is difficult to twist a long rod as compared to small rod" is wrong.

4. Hollow shaft is much stronger than a solid rod of same length and same mass:
For a given mass and length, a hollow shaft has a larger radius than a solid shaft. Since the torque required to twist a cylinder scales with the fourth power of the radius (r4), distributing the mass further from the axis of rotation significantly increases its torsional rigidity. Hence, a hollow shaft is much stronger (can resist more twisting torque) than a solid rod of the same mass and length. This statement is correct.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemistry, mathematics, physics

  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemical engineering, mathematics, physics